Friday, January 27, 2017

Discussion of Disabilities

Our discussion on Friday about Nancy Mairs' essay titled "Disability" had strongly reminded me about some disabled students at Troy High.  I will briefly write about one of these disabled students, Ann.*  I do not exactly know what type of disability Ann has, but I can describe what I know about her condition.  She seems to be unable to move most of her limbs, which forces her to ride in a wheelchair.  When she talks, her words are slightly challenging to understand since her mouth is partially paralyzed (which I concluded from my observations, but I don't know for sure).  When I first saw Ann, I thought "Oh dear, what a poor, crippled girl!"  I later regretted saying that statement in my mind.  The reason why is that I wasn't viewing Ann as an ordinary human at the time (even though I thought that I did so at that moment).  I was perceiving Ann as a helpless "cripple" (Mairs 14).  I realized this former perception when I read Mairs' statement of how she is "not... Ms. MS, a walking, talking embodiment of a chronic incurable degenerative disease" (14).  That sentence made me feel that I was amorally discriminating against Ann (and other disabled people) by saying "It must be terrible to live with disabilities!"  Thanks to Mairs, I now know that in order to treat disabled people as ordinary, I will have to behave as if the disabled people I meet have no disabilities.  (I am not saying that I will make a lie that disabled people do not have disabilities).

I know that I could have written a fictional narrative about a person with disabilities instead of mentioning Ann, but I am not qualified to write such a story.  That is because I am not disabled, so I wouldn't completely understand how disabled people would feel.   While it is true that I some idea of disabled people's emotions, I would have to be disabled myself to get the true understanding.  I can find a way to give myself a disability, but I am not willing to do that.

*Names of Troy High School students have been changed, so don't bother looking up any names in the yearbook.

3 comments:

  1. Nice post Joseph! I liked your compelling personal anecdote about your feelings towards Ann and how they changed as a result of Mairs's article.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think it is cool how you made a connection between what we talked about in class and your real life. A lot of the time people will take more away from what they learn if they can find some way to relate to it. Mairs's article obviously helped you reach a deeper understanding of people in your day to day life, and I commend you for your open mind.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice post joseph! I enjoyed your anecdote and personal thoughts on the subject.

    ReplyDelete